Hi,
Its too soon that I have come up with my second blog but I couldn't resist. As it is Dhulendi today(Holi-2nd day). I was at holi-pujan last night in our neighborhood and there was something I found not only disturbing but quite alarming. 10-15 houses in our neighborhood had come together to make a 'holika' out of woods and dried cow-dung. In the evening, when I had gone for a small tour of the local area, same was the case almost everywhere. People were celebrating in groups of 10-15 houses. In earlier days and a smaller town(Chandausi), I know that a single pyre of wood was made for a much larger group of houses. You might ask 'What's the problem?'. Problems are many, people are growing apart, one major feature of Indian society was its unity which is diminishing(atleast in bigger cities). But the issue I have in mind is wood. What happens when everyone starts celebrating a nuclear festival? More consumption of wood per person for the celebrations. The most alarming thing is that even though people do realize that the cost of wood is soaring, they make it a point to try and get as much fire-wood as possible(maybe as a status symbol). And what happened when they piled up woods in a heap? It took them an hour to get the fire going. There was no space for air(oxygen) for the combustion of woods. A much better model for the pyre would have been if the logs had been placed in concentric cones. It would have saved lots of wood, money and, of course, air. Another thing I might suggest is for everyone to go home and pray around their cooking gas at home. It is as holy a fire as you could get. It(LPG) is the one providing you with food now and not wood as was the case when logically people started to celebrate Holi for the ripening of Wheat crops. I am not against celebrating the festival, but one should realize that the situation when these festivals were started and now are wholly different. There lies no sense in burning the woods now and Holi is not the only festival in India to have this tradition of burning fire-wood. Wood is considered sacred but it is because it was the source of food, heat, comfort in older times. I would, of course, not suggest anyone to start considering petrol as sacred now. It would do to petrol what we have already done to wood and, directly as a result of it, to the forests. I don't think these thoughts of mine are going to start any change in 'traditions'(whether right or wrong, traditions are traditions and people do follow them) but I would like you to think and that is my work done for now. I will be back soon.
7 comments:
Dear Kush,
I read your article on Holi. It is good but not very cl;ear what you really want to say. I am not a very conventional type of hindu but i would like to know do you really know why we really have this sacred fire?
@anonymous:
If you are referring to the 'story' of Harinyakashyap and his son, yes, I know about that too but I do not consider that to be the reason behind why our ancestors started this festival. The Indian festival are in too much sync with the crop cycle for me to ignore and I believe stories do evolve over time. Now, do I really know why we have this sacred fire. No, I do not really know but I have my views. I do not believe in the mythology related with Holika so I have adopted the different version of crop cycle. I believe we used to have this 'sacred' fire to check whether the wheat crop has ripened.
Dear Kush
First of all would like to congratulate you for the revolutionary idea regarding celebration of Holi. It is the concern of everyone to save our environment as well as natural resources. .I also agree that LPG can also be as holy as fire as we could but
Don’t you think that the purpose of Holi celebration will entirely be changed.
The concept behind the “Holika Dahan” is to offer all the negative thoughts and habits to the sacred fire and and live unitedly splashing the colours of happiness togetherness,peace and prosperity. If we do it individually worshipping the LPG gas then the purpose of celebrating this festival will entirely be void . Secondly we celebrate holy once in a year .So I think it is not as dangerous as the harmful gases emitted by the vehicles and CFCs which are used in alarming numbers daily. So according to me we should pay more concern about minimizing the use of vehicles and development of other alternative source of Petrol , diesel and plastic which is a measure threat to our environment
With Best Wishes
Mamta Sharma
(Mrs Mamta Shenoy)
Dear Madam,
What I had intended with this blog was not to suggest an entirely new approach to the celebration of Holi but to show where we are going wrong. The suggestion of use of LPG was just to create an extension to what is going on. I had pointed out that people in smaller groups celebrate the festival now and as work culture grows in metros, we'll have more nuclear families and even lesser interaction among neighbours. So, my suggestion was not exactly something I would like to see implemented. And yes, I agree we should try to reduce other sources of pollution, but in the post I was mainly concerned with the forests and in India major consumption of wood is in construction and then for the sacred purposes. I would like to see that decrease definitively.
With refernence to your response given to 'anonymous 'I have a question . Do You think that the said story is simply out of imagination and it has nothing to do with the reality?. What I want to say is that our mythology is totally based on reasons and it is quite scientific. New inventions and disoveries may prove its validity in times to come . Sprituality starts where science ends and we have many instances which shows the advancement of science and technology in our ancient scriptures . Cloning and Geneteic Engineering were well advanced that time take the example of 'Narasimha Avatar' Moreover our scriptures also propose the theory of Evaluation . How can you say that the stories related to the festival Holy is symbolic and frictional.
With Best Wishes
mamta sharma
(Mrs mamta Shenoy)
Dear Madam,
I do not believe the entire story is false. I said stories do evolve over time. Something like that must have happened but it simply got magnified. And it is very true that scriptures point to things which we are achieving now due to scientific advancements but I believe you might know about Arthur C Clarke as well. He was a sci-fi author and many of his ideas were achieved scientifically because he gave the idea. He has also been credited to have made the thought of going to moon seem possible and only after that scientists started working on that. So if we see it that way, fiction always stays ahead of reality.
Dear Kush
I really appreciate the way you respond and of course your writing style .It is really admirable but I do not agree with your response.
Firstly we cannot ever compare our scriptures with Clarke’s Sci-fi Stories because he was born in the year 1917 and he gave the ideas somewhere around 1940s whereas our scriptures are written quite long ago. And since he was in Air Force so he thought about satellite communications but our Rishi Munis knew almost everything at the time when there was no such resources according to us.
Secondly I don’t think he should be given credit for astronauts going to the moon(as you have written) because he himself has once said “I'm sure we would not have had men on the Moon if it had not been for Wells and Verne and the people who write about this and made people think about it. I'm rather proud of the fact that I know several astronauts who became astronauts through reading my books. “
(Arthur C. Clarke, Address to US Congress, 1975).So it is Wells and Verne who r responsible
Thirdly Long before Clarke , Johannes Kepler discovered the laws governing the motion of the planets, also composed a story about a Moon voyage in 1643. Kepler would prove to be an ideal role model for Clarke.
Last but not the least the most famous and fascinating idea of Clarke that is ‘Time Machine’ is still made to be true and time will tell when it is really going to b executed and in the scriptures also you will find this concept
I know I am going away from the context what you really meant to say .
With Best wishes
Mamta Sharma,
Post a Comment